Search

Campaigners mount legal challenge against Sainsbury’s on edge of nature reserve in Stoke Newington

PUBLISHED: 09:00 12 October 2013

Campaigners are issuing a judicial review against proposals for a Sainsbury's and flats in  Stoke Newington Hight  Street and Wilmer Place

Campaigners are issuing a judicial review against proposals for a Sainsbury's and flats in Stoke Newington Hight Street and Wilmer Place

Archant

Campaigners are mounting a legal challenge against a supermarket giant’s bid to build a mega store in the heart of Stoke Newington.

Earlier this year Hackney Council approved revised plans by Newmark Properties to knock down existing homes and businesses and build a Sainsbury’s and 53 flats at the junction of Wilmer Place and Stoke Newington High Street – despite opposition from local residents and businesses.

The campaigners, spearheaded by group Stokey Local, believe that the council’s planning committee failed to follow application processes properly. They issued a bid for a judicial review at the High Court.

They say their grounds for the review are that the council failed to properly determine that an environmental impact assessment was necessary, it did not properly assess policy on heritage and the harm caused to the area, and it kept the financial viability statement on social housing unnecessarily secret.

The High Court is currently considering the application and, if approved, it would be heard in the next six months.

Following the group’s bid for a legal review, Newmark Properties has, at a cost of £39,000, submitted a new planning application in an attempt to speed up the process.

The twist in the two-year saga has bemused campaigners.

Stokey Local member Nick Perry said: “This shows that the application gives our legal argument for judicial review some credence but it doesn’t explore the reasons behind it.”

He said the revised application “should be considered by a higher authority with greater experience of these issues. We have no faith that the council has the expertise to assess this application fairly”.

Stokey Local is funding the judicial review through donations from opponents of the development.

They believe it will have a detrimental impact on Abney Park nature reserve and independent shops in the area.

The group managed to raise more than £10,000 in three weeks from 250 people after it made an appeal for funding.

Mr Perry said it showed the “strength of feeling” against the proposals.

Cllr Vincent Stops, chair of the planning committee, said: “The decision to grant permission for the revised plans was taken in line with planning regulations.

“Whilst members of the committee shared the concerns of residents, we would not have been able to reject plans based on public opinion alone.

“Had the plans been rejected, the council’s decision could easily have been overturned, allowing the developers to proceed with their original plans for the site.”

A spokesperson for Newmark Properties: “We strongly refute the reasons cited for a judicial review and that is why we have sought to contest them.

“Whilst we respect the legal process, we have submitted an identical planning application to expedite the matter.

“This will give LB Hackney an opportunity to address the concerns raised by Nick Perry on the application process, which is what is being challenged, not the decision itself.

“Therefore this approach will avoid the costs and delays of the judiciary process which should be welcomed by all parties.”

n. Campaigners are asking people to sign a petition to the Secretary of State asking him to use his powers to “call in” the latest application and have it decided by the planning inspectorate rather than Hackney council. To sign the petition, visit http://chn.ge/1hn9xHg.

0 comments

Latest Hackney News Stories

11:13

“Pinball Geoff” Harvey has been dealing in pinball machines for decades – and when he’s not doing that he’s drumming around Hackney with Mexican surf group the Bikini Beach Band.

CCTV has been released of the moment a prisoner made his escape from Homerton Hospital in his socks, being chased by a medic and the police officer who was supposed to be guarding him.

09:52

An ensemble of young singers from across Hackney is looking to swell its membership following a stellar performance at the Music for Youth National Festival in Birmingham.

Yesterday, 17:47

It’s just as likely that you know Rev Sue Makin from social media as from St Mary of Eton in Hackney Wick. She tells Emma Bartholomew how the church can be an ‘unshockable’ listening ear

Yesterday, 11:58

Bike tracks could be installed along Wick Road as part of Hackney Council’s plans to make the borough safer for cyclists and pedestrians.

Yesterday, 10:24

A controversial late-night levy for traders selling booze after midnight is set to be voted on tomorrow night by Hackney councillors.

Yesterday, 09:03

A derelict Art-Deco cinema in Stoke Newington Road will reopen as a theatre and music venue after police backed down over capacity demands.

Yesterday, 07:00

An academic programme for former Chelsea FC players making the transfer away from football as part of an ‘aftercare’ scheme is being set up by the Institute for Sport Business at its Hackney Wick campus.

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists

Competitions

Now in its 11th year, Field Day is bringing together an exceptional mix of artists and genres once more to an east London park.