Council tax hell for Hackney photographer

PUBLISHED: 12:35 08 February 2012

David O'Shaughnessy has had a two year legal battle with Hackney Council over Council Tax payments.

David O'Shaughnessy has had a two year legal battle with Hackney Council over Council Tax payments.


A man the town hall claimed owed more than £2,000 in unpaid council tax, has won a his battle after he was unfairly hounded for what should have been his former landlord’s arrears.

Photographer David O’Shaughnessy endured a nightmare of stress anxiety and sleepless nights as Hackney Council repeatedly threatened him with court action and baliffs for the outstanding 10-year-old debt.

In 2009, five years after he had been a tenant in a now demolished house in Seal Street, Upper Clapton, he received a bill for the unpaid council tax.


He disputed liability, because the law since 1992 requires owners and not tenants to pay council tax on multi-occupation dwellings – but the council continued to demand payment.

A recent Valuation Tribunal upheld his appeal, ruling it was his former landlord and not him who was liable for the arrears.

Mr O’Shaughnessy, who now lives in Furrow Lane, Homerton said “This has caused untold and unnecessary stress to me, my family and friends.”

Backed by Zacchaeus 2000 Trust (Z2K), a specialist debt advice charity, Mr O’Shaughnessy is now making a formal complaint against the council and is calling for an investigation into what he claims is a “fraudulent” rent book used by the council as evidence against him.

Alan Murdie, senior lawyer at Z2K said many questions still need answering: “We cannot explain why Hackney Council was so relentless pursuing Mr O’Shaughnessy, rather than the landlord concerned.

“The council also made serious mistakes with the facts, evidence and the law in Mr O’Shaughnessy’s case.”

Cabinet member for finance Cllr Samantha Lloyd said all council tax cases were dealt with based on the information provided by owners, landlords and tenants and, in most cases, any disputes were resolved quickly.

The council has yet to pay £200 compensation awarded to O’Shaughnessy by the Local Government Ombudsman for mishandling his initial complaint in 2009.

Latest Hackney Stories


England suddenly had to battle to stay in the match on day three of the Ashes after Steve Smith’s outstanding hundred helped to pile the pressure back on them at the Gabba.

James Brophy is one of many players absent for the O’s at Plainmoor

Wondering what the weather has in store for us this weekend? Watch our three-minute Met Office video forecast.

Yesterday, 18:40

It is a huge relief that the seven-year-old boy hit by a car outside St John the Baptist Primary School wasn’t more badly hurt.

Yesterday, 18:14

Hackney Council has unveiled what are thought to be the UK’s first public speed monitors for cyclists in an attempt to slow them down in London Fields.

Yesterday, 18:07

A rapist who preyed on two lone women making their way home after a night out in Leicester Square has today been locked up for 10 years.

Yesterday, 17:16

The fate of Haggerston Baths will be decided on Monday after a consultation found most people would rather see it turned into shops than a hotel.

Yesterday, 15:00

Clapton assistant manager Wayne Seal is looking forward to facing his former club Ilford this weekend.

Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists