Search

Old Street cycle death trial: Jurors urged to ‘put aside prejudice’ as they retire

PUBLISHED: 16:15 21 August 2017 | UPDATED: 16:53 21 August 2017

Charlie Alliston, 20, outside the Old Bailey on Monday. Picture: Nick Ansell/PA Wire

Charlie Alliston, 20, outside the Old Bailey on Monday. Picture: Nick Ansell/PA Wire

Jurors in the Charlie Alliston bicycle death trial this afternoon began deliberations – after being urged by the judge to “put aside feelings of prejudice”.

Matthew Briggs, husband of Kim Briggs, outside the Old Bailey. Picture: Nick Ansell/PA Wire Matthew Briggs, husband of Kim Briggs, outside the Old Bailey. Picture: Nick Ansell/PA Wire

Mr Alliston, 20, denies the manslaughter of Kim Briggs, as well as causing actual bodily harm by “wanton or furious driving”. Alliston, 20, was cycling in Old Street on February 12 last year when he collided with mum-of-two Mrs Briggs, 44.

He was said to be travelling at up to 14 mph when he collided with her. Jurors heard Alliston was riding a “fixie” or fixed-gear bike with no front brake – which is illegal on UK roads. He allegedly shouted at her to “get out of the way” twice before their heads smashed together.

After summing up, Judge Wendy Joseph told the Old Bailey jury: “It’s hard to think of a case that’s more likely to rouse your emotions. A young man who was 18 at the time. A woman in her 40s with her life ahead of her.

“Put to one side feelings of emotion, feelings of sympathy, feelings of revulsion, feelings of prejudice.”

The fixed-gear track bicycle being ridden by Charlie Alliston when he collided with 44-year-old Kim Briggs as she crossed Old Street last year. Picture: CPS/PA Wire The fixed-gear track bicycle being ridden by Charlie Alliston when he collided with 44-year-old Kim Briggs as she crossed Old Street last year. Picture: CPS/PA Wire

In his closing speech before the jury was sent out, Mark Wyeth, defending Alliston, questioned the manslaughter charge. He said: “I ask as a matter of common sense and looking across all the evidence: is this really manslaughter? Really?

“We’ve had an eloquent speech from [prosecutor] Mr [Duncan] Penny, we’ve had mood music all around this case and, yes, it’s a tragedy for the Briggs family. It’s also a tragedy for the Alliston family.”

“The counsel of perfection that the prosecution put forward is so complete [that] if you reversed the outcome – if Mr Alliston went over the handlebars, had fractured his skull and died and Mrs Briggs got up and dusted herself off – what’s to stop her from being prosecuted for manslaughter on the approach the prosecution take, because she should not have been there?”

It is accepted that Mrs Briggs stepped backwards into Alliston’s path while crossing the street.

Kim Briggs died days after the collision in Old Street. Picture: Met Police Kim Briggs died days after the collision in Old Street. Picture: Met Police

My Wyeth added: “I’m not criticising Mrs Briggs.”

He also suggested it was unlikely that a driver in Alliston’s position would face the same charge: “If you drove your car really dangerously and at very high speed, you might get prosecuted for what’s called gross negligence manslaughter. You might.

“But this defendant is not getting prosecuted for gross negligence manslaughter. He is getting prosecuted for unlawful act manslaughter. As drivers, the prospects you would be prosecuted for unlawful act manslaughter are very slender.”

He added Mrs Briggs had not used the pedestrian crossing 30 feet away from where the pair collided and Alliston had right of way.

Kim Briggs died following the collision. Picture: Met Police/PA Wire Kim Briggs died following the collision. Picture: Met Police/PA Wire

“This is not a case of somebody jumping the lights,” he said. “This is not a case of an approach speed on this bike that was illegal. It’s a 30mph area and the hazards that were in that road were not of Mr Alliston’s making.”

Court reporting by Press Association

Latest Hackney Stories

The two defenders produced an excellent display on Saturday after a testing start to help prevent Sutton United from getting much joy out wide

Wayne Asher tells Emma Bartholomew about the ‘lunatic’ ring road scheme that threatened to plough an eight-lane motorway through Hackney – and was only scrapped after 30 years of destroying the local property market

Yesterday, 19:37

Arsenal take on West Ham at the London Stadium on Wednesday evening after a disappointing performance during a 1-1 draw at Southampton.

Yesterday, 18:45

Plans to introduce a supergroup formed by the borough’s schools have been announced by Hackney Council.

Yesterday, 18:26

Bosses at a brand new ’50s-themed rock ‘n’ roll pub are smarting after thieves broke in and stole guitars and cash one week after it opened its doors.

Yesterday, 17:30

Darting royalty Dennis Priestley, Martin Adams and Bobby George have stepped up to the oche in the fight against prostate cancer, attending an exclusive event at a pub that has signed up as a Men United Arms venue in London.

Yesterday, 16:49

Emma Bartholomew stays at Cove Cottages in St Agnes with her family, where they take surf lessons en masse in the bay right below

Yesterday, 16:11

The future looks bright for Simon Marks Jewish Primary School after the opening of its new building for nursery- and reception-age children.

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists