Search

Save Dalston Lane campaign beats the odds to secure judicial review

PUBLISHED: 11:41 13 October 2014 | UPDATED: 14:42 13 October 2014

Dalston Lane last century.

Dalston Lane last century.

Archant

Campaigners fighting to save a row of Georgian houses from demolition by Hackney Council have beaten the odds and got past the first hurdle in their application for a judicial review.

A row of Gerogian terraceson Dalston Lane have been earmarked for demolition A row of Gerogian terraceson Dalston Lane have been earmarked for demolition

A barrister for conservation group Open (Organisation for Promotion of Environmental Needs) Dalston argued at the Royal Courts of Justice on Friday against a decision made at the council’s planning committee in March, which gave the green light to total demolition of the historic houses in Dalston Lane.

The council has entered into a £2.38million deal with Murphy Homes for the construction of 44 homes – none of which is classed as “affordable” – and 1,000 square metres of open-plan retail space.

An engineer from Murphy advised the council that it was impossible to retain the 19th-century Georgian facades, because the “crumbling” bricks would render the scheme “structurally unsound”.

But Open’s barrister countered this by saying that an independent structural engineer appointed by the council had reported that there was nothing wrong with the bricks and it would be possible to save the facades if a different design was used.

The High Court judge, Mr Justice Foskett, who also heard from a barrister representing the council, said he was persuaded that Open Dalston had an arguable case that council officers had failed in their duty to consider alternative possibilities for developing the site.

He granted a full day’s hearing next month.

Bill Parry-Davies, founder of Open Dalston, told the Gazette following the hearing that he “felt like jumping up and down”.

“We are delighted. 80 per cent of applicants fail at this stage,” he said.

“We are hugely grateful for people who put their hands in their pockets to contribute to the fight against municipal vandalism.

“We have had many people in the community donating small sums of money, which has added up to big sums of money which has enabled us to pay for this today.”

He estimated that the proceedings had cost the council about £15-20,000 so far.

“We regret they haven’t responded to our attempts to have a discussion and that they have spent our public money in engaging in the fight to date,” he said.

The group is still calling on the council to meet with the Spitalfields Trust, which has costed detailed plans that include the provision of affordable housing.

Architect Lisa Shell, who is organising the Save Dalston Lane campaign, said: “This is important to all of us personally in Dalston, because the buildings represent our heritage and our local identity.

“They are a finite resource. As homogenisation across London goes on, they come more valuable.

“Those buildings were standing in open fields when they were built, in a country lane.”

The group is still calling on the council to meet with the Spittlefields Trust, which has put forward alternative costed detailed plans, which include affordable housing.

Latest Hackney News Stories

07:18

The mum of a five-year-old boy who suffered devastating injuries after being run over on his Lower Clapton estate has begged witnesses to come forward.

15 minutes ago

A mental health chief who used her own breakdown to encourage others to seek help has been presented with a “special achievement award” by the Cavell Nurses’ Trust charity.

Yesterday, 16:57

Hackney’s Boxing Academy has been named “alternative provision school of the year” at the TES Schools Awards.

Yesterday, 15:53

Our Lady’s Convent High School teachers are set to follow Stoke Newington School staff by going on strike.

Yesterday, 12:45

Each week, the Gazette takes to the streets to unearth something being manufactured right here in Hackney. This week we visit Square Root Soda’s HQ in Hackney Downs to hear more about the unusually flavoured soft drinks they produce.

Yesterday, 11:02

A convicted paedophile who was banned from keeping Chihuahuas because he used them to “attract girls” has been locked up – again – after police found a box of kids’ toys in his flat.

Yesterday, 08:11

A burglar who stole £18,000 in heirlooms from a Shoreditch flat to fuel his crack cocaine addiction has been jailed for six years.

Tue, 18:03

An environmentally friendly scheme to make streets in Hackney safer for schoolchildren has been given the seal of approval by excited children.

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists

Competitions

Now in its 11th year, Field Day is bringing together an exceptional mix of artists and genres once more to an east London park.