Search

Dad kicked out of Hackney Central Library for ‘reading too loudly’ to autistic daughter, 5

PUBLISHED: 10:52 04 April 2017 | UPDATED: 17:09 04 April 2017

Adam Marks with his daughter Susan. Picture: Adam Marks

Adam Marks with his daughter Susan. Picture: Adam Marks

Archant

A dad and his five-year-old autistic daughter were kicked out of Hackney Central Library – because he was reading too loudly.

Adam Marks with his daughter Susan. Picture: Adam Marks Adam Marks with his daughter Susan. Picture: Adam Marks

Adam Marks was reading to his daughter Susan in the children’s section on Friday afternoon when he was reprimanded by a security guard for disrupting other library users.

He had been reading one of Susan’s favourite books, about turning frowns upside down, for fewer than 10 minutes.

“It was quite humiliating,” Adam told the Gazette, “but the worst thing is just that it was so daft.

“We were in the children’s section. If I’d been reading in the study section I would have understood it, but why can’t I read to my daughter in the children’s section? The library is for everyone.”

Adam, 37, has to read particularly clearly to Susan due to her autism.

"Why can’t I read to my daughter in the children’s section? The library is for everyone"

Adam Marks

“You have to enunciate because of the way her brain is wired,” he said. “She’s easily distracted by other noises.”

Susan’s condition means she requires extra guidance with reading. But according to her dad, a clerk in the NHS, she loves listening to stories.

“She loves books and especially likes being read to,” he said. But it takes twice as long for her to understand what’s being read out.”

Hackney’s community services boss Cllr Jon Burke said: “It appears a security guard who is a contractor working in the library may have acted-over zealously on this occasion.

“We welcome parents reading to their children in all our libraries and something clearly went wrong in this case.

“We will be making contact with Mr Marks to apologise and hope he and Susan will return to their local library soon.”

Hackney libraries’ terms and conditions state: “Library staff may refuse to loan items and may deny the use of a library to anyone who [...] behaves in a manner which is anti-social or which may disturb other library users.”

The family, who live in Lower Clapton, are regular library-goers – something Adam insists will carry on despite Friday’s incident.

What do you think? E-mail gazette.letters@archant.co.uk.

Related articles

1 comment

  • So how is reading to a child anti social or disturbing other people in the childrens section . Does she not have the right to learn also!

    Report this comment

    Jennifer Marks

    Tuesday, April 4, 2017

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Latest Hackney Stories

22:30

Spurs captain disappointed with defeat to north London rivals Arsenal, but keen not to blame referee Mike Dean for the loss at the Emirates

For the final word on the superb victory over Spurs on Saturday here’s Ella Meadwocroft’s must-read column as she hails Arsenal, saying North London is still very much red...

09:48

England’s women were edged out by a solitary in their second match at the Hockey World League Final in New Zealand.

Yesterday, 19:10

Embleton full of praise for Sam Sargeant and explains how he will stay in charge for as long as the club needs

National League: Leyton Orient 1 Dover Athletic 1

Yesterday, 16:47

Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger has hailed his team after they outclassed and outfought bitter rivals Spurs 2-0 at the Emirates on Saturday.

Yesterday, 16:19

A visibly disappointed Mauricio Pochettino has insisted his Tottenham Hotspur side were the better side, especially before they conceded the first goal in a 2-0 defeat against Arsenal.

Yesterday, 15:58

Arsenal’s comprehensive 2-0 victory over Spurs in the North London derby raised more questions than answers about the future of Alexis Sanchez and Mesut Ozil.

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists