Search

Jewish burial society launches bid to take senior coroner Mary Hassell to court over ‘faith deaths’ row

PUBLISHED: 15:27 25 January 2018 | UPDATED: 14:37 26 January 2018

Mary Hassell has been senior coroner for north London since 2013

Mary Hassell has been senior coroner for north London since 2013

Archant

An Orthodox Jewish charity today applied to take senior north London coroner Mary Hassell to court over her controversial decision to stop prioritising religious burials.

If successful, it will spark a judicial review that could see the move reversed. It comes as a string of high-profile politicians and faith leaders have called for her resignation.

Ms Hassell – whose remit covers Hackney, Tower Hamlets, Islington and Camden – has come under intense criticism in recent weeks from local Jewish and Muslim communities over the decision.

Under Jewish and Islamic law, bodies must be buried on the day of death or as soon as possible afterwards. Both faiths also view invasive post-mortems as desecration, preferring CT body scans.

Relations between the coroner’s office and faith representatives broke down in October over a decision by Ms Hassell to withdraw special burial arrangements that were struck three years ago.

Ms Hassell agreed in January 2015 that most Jewish people who die at home in north London could be immediately sent to the Carmel Funeral Home in Stamford Hill instead of going to a public mortuary as is standard. But the arrangement was cancelled in October after a row broke out about delays dealing with a man who had died of natural causes.

Ms Hassell claimed the society made persistent requests to one of her officers for a post mortem to be carried out the next working day, but that staffing issues meant this could not happen.

The application is being brought by the Adath Yisroel Burial Society (AYBS) in Stamford Hill, and is supported by the Board of Deputies of British Jews, who have called for Ms Hassell to be removed from office, and Chief Rabbi Ephraim Mirvis.

Rabbi Asher Gratt of the AYBS, bringing the claim, said: “Mary Hassell’s conduct is having a devastating effect on members of the Jewish and Muslim Communities who are being put through great anguish by her – suffering the distress of not being permitted to bury their loved ones in the dignity they deserve according to our tradition and belief.

“She has alienated the communities she is meant to serve and we are left with no option but to seek that she be transferred to a less diverse area.”

The AYBS denied leaving the coroner’s officer feeling “persecuted” with its repeated phone calls and e-mails, and said had they known the coroner was dealing with another faith death they would have accepted the situation.

Asher said: “As far as I am aware the AYBS volunteers would always speak with the coroner and coroner’s officers in an even-handed and calm manner.

“However, where it is felt necessary, in order to enable someone to be buried quickly, we will try to make sure that all reasonable efforts to achieve that are made, either by phoning the coroner’s office ourselves or instructing our solicitors to take appropriate steps, which does not amount to bullying.”

1 comment

  • I wish to address one paragraph in the above article stating that “The AYBS has not directly answered allegations it had left the coroner’s officer feeling “persecuted” with its repeated phone calls and e-mails, or that she had ended up delaying other important work so she could deal with the man’s case despite the staff shortage”. As far as I am aware the AYBS volunteers would always speak with the coroner and coroner’s officers in an even-handed and calm manner. Likewise, the solicitor Mr. Asserson and his staff do the same and the tone of their correspondence is balanced and reasonable. However, where it is felt necessary, in order to enable someone to be buried quickly, we will try to make sure that all reasonable efforts to achieve that are made, either by phoning the coroner’s office ourselves or instructing our solicitors to take appropriate steps, which does not amount to bullying. Furthermore, we were never told that the Coroner's office was dealing with another faith death. Had it been explained to us that this was causing delay we would, of course, have accepted that. However, where we were effectively being given no response, we persevered. There was no bullying, however. It is clear without a doubt that Muslims and Jews are almost the only people who ever ask for a speedy release of a body. Whilst everyone is usually concerned to have information as to what is to happen to the body, most people in Britain are however in no particular hurry to have the body of the deceased released. Accordingly, the fact that someone is occasionally given speedy treatment will pass entirely unnoticed by and will have no material effect on the families connected to other bodies requiring attention. No one will feel unfairly treated if the diverse needs of a tiny minority are catered for, as is regularly done by other coroners.

    Report this comment

    Asher Gratt

    Friday, January 26, 2018

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Latest Hackney Stories

National League: AFC Fylde 0 Leyton Orient 1

The O’s head coach Justin Edinburgh has plenty of options available to him ahead of facing the Coasters

15:00

A decision to prune back and eventually cut down two 250-year-old trees in Clissold Park has angered environmentalists.

Yesterday, 20:15

A 92-year-old woman is fighting for her life after being hit by a car in Stoke Newington Church Street early this morning.

Yesterday, 17:57

When Auro Foxcroft first walked into forgotten Art Deco gem the Savoy Cinema two years ago it was covered in pigeon poo, cobwebs and piles of junk.

Spurs are set to be without top goalscorer Harry Kane for Sunday’s match against Keith Hill’s League One strugglers

Yesterday, 15:00

Clapton assistant manager Wayne Seal wants his side to keep piling the pressure on the top four in the Essex Senior League.

Yesterday, 13:08

Environment chiefs are struggling to contain a crude oil spillage that has been spreading down the River Lea through Hackney since Sunday.

PROMOTED CONTENT

To celebrate LGBT history month, Hackney resident Amanda talks about her journey to becoming a foster carer, with the council’s support and training.

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists