Readers' Letters

Editor’s comment: School run ban does not go far enough

PUBLISHED: 18:40 24 November 2017 | UPDATED: 18:50 24 November 2017

Pupils, some dressed as zebras, campaign at the crossing earlier this year.

Pupils, some dressed as zebras, campaign at the crossing earlier this year.


It is a huge relief that the seven-year-old boy hit by a car outside St John the Baptist Primary School wasn’t more badly hurt.

It is far better to be reporting on a near miss than an outright tragedy.

When the council consulted on banning school run traffic from Crondall Street, immediately outside the school, 70 per cent of parents said they opposed the move in an online poll. I wonder if any of those will now be reconsidering their position.

This collision happened on a zebra crossing immediately next to a primary school. It’s hard to imagine a place where pedestrians have such unequivocal right of way over cars. While this was undoubtedly an accident, it’s a reminder as far as I’m concerned that cars have no place near a school at all.

Some might say this wouldn’t have happened had the child been dropped off by car at the school gates, something parents are now banned from doing.

The same tired argument – that traffic schemes make roads more dangerous, polluted or congested – is trotted out over traffic filtering schemes when those nearby complain that cars have simply been displaced into their roads. We hear it when drivers complain that cycle lanes are “taking up” space on roads. It’s nonsense. Our roads are bad not because of anti-driving schemes, but because those schemes don’t go far enough.

Our space is too limited, our fuel too dirty and our air too toxic for people to keep driving, and buying cars, at the rate we have been used to. We need schemes like this to go further, and risk unpopularity.

I take my hat off to the headteacher who pushed ahead with this scheme because she recognised it was the right thing to do – not for the convenience of parents, but for the health and futures of her young students.

Note: This column as it originally appeared in print yesterday stated that 70 per cent of parents had opposed the school streets scheme outside St John the Baptist. In fact, that was in a poll conducted by the school, but was followed by an official consultation that showed majority support for the scheme among both parents and neighbours. I’m sorry for any confusion caused by this genuine error.

Related articles

Latest Hackney Stories

The contrast between the two managers during their post-match interviews could not have been more pronounced. While tired-looking Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger bemoaned bad luck but refused to address the gulf in class between the two sides – as Manchester City routed the Gunners 3-0 at Wembley to deservedly lift the 2018 Caraboa Cup – Pep Guardiola spoke powerfully and eloquently about Catalonian independence and his support for jailed politicians.

Arsene Wenger bemoaned bad luck as his team were utterly outplayed by Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City as they beat sorry Arsenal 3-0 in the Carabao Cup final at Wembley Stadium on Sunday.

Arsenal took on Manchester City in the 2018 Carabao Cup final at Wembley Stadium on Sunday. Read Arsenal reporter Layth Yousif’s PLAYER RATINGS from the showpiece match.

Pep Guardiola won his 22nd trophy as a manager as his Manchester City side comprehensively beat Arsenal 3-0 in the Carabao Cup final at Wembley on Sunday.


Ben Pearce reflects on Spurs’ important Premier League win at Selhurst Park earlier today


Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger replied immediately when asked the question.

Yesterday, 23:10

Sunday’s League Cup final is eagerly-awaited by a large number of Arsenal fans. Read on as a number of loyal supporters explained to Layth Yousif what the trophy means to them.


To celebrate LGBT history month, Hackney resident Amanda talks about her journey to becoming a foster carer, with the council’s support and training.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read

Show Job Lists