Revealed: How political parties are using Facebook ‘dark adverts’ to target Hackney voters
PUBLISHED: 15:01 08 June 2017 | UPDATED: 15:27 08 June 2017
Political parties have targeted people in Hackney more than 200 times in the last six weeks using Facebook “dark adverts” to try and influence votes.
As voters head to the polls, the Gazette can reveal how political ads containing specific messages have played a part in local campaigning.
So called Facebook “dark ads” are personalised commercials shown to different users based on age, sex and interests.
Some groups blame this type of advertising for strongly influencing last year’s Brexit vote.
Will Moy, director of independent fact checking website Full Fact, said: “It’s possible to target dark ads at millions of people in this country without the rest of us knowing about it.
“Inaccurate information could be spreading with no one to scrutinise it.”
Unlike billboards or TV ads, which everyone can see, targeted Facebook advertising is unique to each user and so is extremely difficult to track. It is currently completely unregulated.
But a new British citizen-data group called Who Targets Me? is attempting to monitor dark ads using an extension on the Chrome browser.
The Gazette has been given access to the data by The Bureau Local, part of The Bureau of Investigative Journalism.
Their sample shows 119 dark adverts were shown to Facebook users in Hackney South and Shoreditch and 85 in Hackney North and Stoke Newington since April 28, although the true figures are likely to be far higher.
Labour posted the most dark ads in both constituencies, 88 in total. Some attack the Liberal Democrats saying: “They broke their promises before and they would do it again.”
The Lib Dems had the second highest number, 60, and focused on pro-EU messages such as “European citizens in Britain, you have a right to stay”.
The Greens had 38. Their “Do you know how Green you are really?” ads showed people agreeing with policies only to find out later they are from the Green Party.
The only Conservative ad, in Hackney South, showed Theresa May speeches about “strong and stable” government.
Louis Knight-Webb, co-founder of Who Targets Me?, said it was important to understand how Facebook dark ads may be influencing elections.
“It’s my personal hope that further down the line this data will be useful in bringing about electoral reform,” he said.
None of the parties commented.
THE NATIONAL PICTURE
How are political parties using dark ads nationally?
According to The Bureau Local, which has analysed data about 889 Facebook dark adverts nationally, the Conservatives are heavily targeting Jeremy Corbyn - with nine out of 10 of their adverts attacking him.
The Labour Party, by contrast, is hardly mentioning Theresa May in its social media campaign with only 9 per cent of the 136 different ads seen referring to the prime minister. The adverts Labour is promoting hardest are not related to policy, but are urging people to get out and vote. The next most common topics addressed in paid-for ads by the party are the NHS and tuition fees.
The Conservatives are focusing most on Brexit, the economy and security, while the Liberal Democrats are using Facebook ads to
talk about Brexit and dementia but also to seek donations.
The data taken from the Facebook feeds of more than 8,000 voters nationally has been gathered by the citizen data project Who Targets Me?.